DesignSpark Mechanicalのレビュー

My Design Spark Mechanical Review

製品を使ってみた感想： I mostly used the software for editing SketchUp files. Since Sketch Up Pro is an expensive product, everyone could use Design Spark Mechanical for free to edit *.skp files.

良いポイント:

It is the first and maybe the only software which imports SketchUp (*.skp) files. If you're a maker person then this software enables a wide array of electronics components via its "RS Components" connection. Actually, the software is launched by them.

改善してほしい点:

Its user interface is a little bit unfamiliar comparing to other well-known CAD softwares.

Fantastic Software for Free!

製品を使ってみた感想： Overall, I'd say that this software works great for me. I've used a number of other 3D modeling packages, and I keep coming back to this one when I need to model up a small part for 3D printing. They seem to be continuing the development of this software and they've kept it free, so what is there to complain about!

良いポイント:

Designspark Mechanical is easy to get started with. The user interface and tools are much more intuitive than some of the other options that I've tried in the past. It is refreshing to see an interface that doesn't have icons and options littered all over the screen. Even though the software is simpler to use, I'm still able to easily model things that are dimensionally accurate. Some of the other "simple" 3D modeling programs are not so great at that.

改善してほしい点:

Although it can do most of what the other software packages can do, sometimes the path to get there can be a bit different. One thing that I struggled with was mirroring of objects. You actually have to make the mirror line before you start drawing, or you just can't mirror things. That takes a little more thought ahead of time to remember that.

Design Spark CAD Design an OK tool

製品を使ってみた感想： - It was good but I had a hard time as there are not many tutorials to follow.
- There is documentation and some tutorials on YouTube I don't feel like is artist friendly like other software. - I like that it does not run off the cloud and does not lag.

良いポイント:

- What I liked the most of this software is that I was able to start designing right away taking care of the basic design needs. - The software is light which makes it good for working and installation times are reduced. - This is not a cloud base software and you can install it in several computers. - Good boolean substraction system it is nice the way it works. - Good if you are coming from an engineering background you will probably get the hang of it quickly. - Comes with a free utility.

改善してほしい点:

- Learning curve is not as easy it will take you time. - Several tools are confusing they require too many steps to get them to work. - Yo purchase the software by modules as addons. - Not easy to get to use it if you come from an artistic background.

Model Based Design can be Simple and Inexpensive

製品を使ってみた感想： We needed a fast and easy to use model based design system for the early development of an energy storage system. We evaluated a number of products and DesignSpark was the best for our needs.

良いポイント:

We use DesignSpark for initial conceptual engineering and simulation. It is by far the easiest and most intuitive model based design platform available.

改善してほしい点:

Would like to see additional export formats that can be input into Computation Fluid Dynamic packages such as Simscale.

Easy to learn. Easy to use. Powerful features. Our go-to CAD program for designing new products.

製品を使ってみた感想： Overall experience has been fantastic. We have been able to create a wide variety of products for our customer base using DSM. With the ability to use STP files we can import files from customers or other designers and modify them to suit our needs.

良いポイント:

Initially the most important feature was how easy to learn the program is for non CAD experts. With direct modeling we were up and creating items within a few minutes. As we gained experience we found more and more ways to create complex items, both mechanical and cosmetic in nature.

改善してほしい点:

There are not a ton of resources for solving issues, but there is a community that often has an answer to point in the right direction. The tutorials available are good, but more of them would be better.

Fast learning curve, excellent price

製品を使ってみた感想： To be honest a significant amount of use for me is quicly sketching things up (ie subsea equipment layout) to email to clients, either screen captures or 3D PDF. I do use it for real mechanical drawings however, for 3D printing as well as sending good quality 2D drawings to our engineering shop (though I did purchase the 'Drawing' Add-on for that)

良いポイント:

Apart from the fact it's free, well the basic package anyway (there are Add-Ons), I don't think you could call any engineering software truly intuitive, but I really was up and designing things the first day. That was in 2015. I wouldn't call myself an expert user, sometimes I won't touch it for weeks or more, but each time I do it always does what I want it to do.

改善してほしい点:

DSM does lack a few features, for instance object colours and decent rendering, and back grounds, though v5 has made significant improvement on those. I was disappointed to find there's almost nothing in the way of built in or online libraries. Communicating with companies who use other packages is becoming more of a problem as dsm can only export a handfull of formats. There is another Add-On which improves that situation though.

free design for professionals

製品を使ってみた感想： I liked it and we can use it in the office

良いポイント:

offer a wide variety of resources and design tools to complete projects including free design tools for PCBs and 3D designs

改善してほしい点:

3D modeling is not complete enough to make a good project

Great for Sketching

製品を使ってみた感想： Great software for what it's worth. Don't expect the world.

良いポイント:

This software is excellent for rough sketches. It doesn't have all the functionality of some of it's competitors, but the price is right.

改善してほしい点:

Wish there were more features available. I learned how to use a different program and there's been quite the learning curve.

DesignSpark Mechanical makes 3D easier

良いポイント:

It's the ease of use. You don't need to be an expert in 3D to use this great software and it made it very easy for me to a lot without limiting me. I was totally blown off by how easier it was to use

改善してほしい点:

It's been great so far and I hope It stays that way

command line

良いポイント:

it is free, it is complete and very professional

改善してほしい点:

i woul like to use a command line with the same commands like in the famous Autocad. So an Autocad operator has not to learn cad again.

Kein Fortschritt vorhanden. CAD System wurde unbrauchbar in der Anwendung

製品を使ってみた感想： Was soll das????

良いポイント:

Kann keine mehr finden. War in der vorherigen Version sehr gut.

改善してほしい点:

Inzwischen umständliche Benutzung. Dauernd muss man von Skizze in 3D umschalten. Nicht mehr logisch aufgebaut.

Früher gut, wird immer schlechter

製品を使ってみた感想： Ich kann verstehen, dass man von Businesskunden mehr Geld verlangen will und kann. Aber warum gleichzeitig die Hobbyisten abwürgen die kostenlose Werbung und Youtube-Tutorials machen?

良いポイント:

Super einfach und intuitiv zu benutzen.

改善してほしい点:

Seit ein paar Versionen werden Funktionen die vorher verfügbar werden in die hochpreisigen Abomodelle verschoben. Für Hobbyisten wird die Software damit zusehends unbrauchbarer. Ich werde sie leider nicht mehr weiterempfehlen.

If You Want Speed and Professional Drawings, Then DesignSpark Mechanical is for You!

製品を使ってみた感想： I'm retired from owning my own Custom Cabinet Business, and now I'm a neophyte inventor. There is no reason why I should pay a "high-priced Professional" for the same quality patent drawings that I can produce myself. So again, DesignSpark Mechanical is the only drawing program for me.

良いポイント:

What impresses me most about DesignSpark Mechanical is how quickly and easily a drawing or object can be created. If you've ever shaped putty into different forms, that's exactly how you produce drawings with DesignSpark Mechanical. Like every drawing program though, you must except the fact, that there will be a learning curve. I possess thirty years experience using AutoCad,which uses a lot of commands foreign to DesignSpark Mechanical. I think this is making my learning curve a little steeper, but I feel it is well worth the time. On the other hand, there are quite a number of very similar commands used in DesignSpark Mechanical. I wouldn't trade DesignSpark Mechanical for any other drawing program. Also, the personal support given to the members is second to none.

改善してほしい点:

I only have one criticism with DesignSpark Mechanical. I have been used to AutoCad instruction books with over a thousand pages. If I came upon something that I wasn't familiar with, all I had to do was to look in the index and go to the relevant page or pages. DesignSpark Mechanical has countless video tutorials and many other resources to get you back on track about a problem you are having. The community forum is also a tremendously helpful site to get information. Everyone there wants to help you. There is no secret keeping. Maybe since I am a fairly new member, there might be a place where you may lookup a command and learn how to properly use it.

Un logiciel rapide, efficace, intuitif, gratuit, ... mais limité.

製品を使ってみた感想： J'utilise DesignSpark Mechanical pour de la création, du design pour l'impression 3D et autres projets personnels.
Je suis complètement ravis d'utiliser DesignSpark, mais l'impossibilité d'enregistrer en STEP et le faite de devoir être tout le temps en ligne, me fait me questionner quand au changement de logiciel...

良いポイント:

Le logiciel est très intuitif dans son utilisation. On arrive rapidement à des modélisations très efficaces. C'est le logiciel CAO le plus simple et facile de ce que j'ai vu, de tout les retours des personnes que je connais, et des discussions sur forums. Il permet un résultat complétement professionnel, et permet de faire de l’impression 3D avec l’export en STL. Le logiciel est gratuit.

改善してほしい点:

Le logiciel est gratuit, mais nécessite d’avoir internet (pas d’utilisation offline) et de créer un compte gratuit. Le gros point noir qui peut peser est qu’il est impossible d’enregistrer l’assemblage dans un format partageable sur un autre logiciel (type STL). Toute les créations sont donc perdue si vous changé de logiciel … Aucun autre logiciel n’ouvrant du RSDOC. Il est impossible également de faire une mise en plan, sans payer un Plugin. On peut acheter un plugin pour exporter en STEP, pour environ 800 euros. Ce qui n’est pas donné pour un maker.

Super 3d model viewer

製品を使ってみた感想： In present work great fast and easy software for opening of step and other 3D models.
With additional benefit - editing.

良いポイント:

Very intuitive . In full version creation of drawings

改善してほしい点:

In some areas it is really difficult to customise for example : *to create customised template of Bill of Materials * to create customised order information

Excellent hope i found this before

製品を使ってみた感想： I just use CAD for personal use. I have been using FreeCAD and QCAD for my most works and used Solid Edge for some projects then a buddy from reddit suggested me DesignSparks. I had a pretty good experience with it. It was soo easy to learn and can do the things in less time compared to other softwares

良いポイント:

Pretty easy to use. Easy learning curve Best of SpaceClaim for Free Stable performance soo far Great Tutorials with well explanation Good support from the community

改善してほしい点:

STEP files can't be exported without the paid plugin, well i found thats reasonable to support the development of this free software.

Great for Quick and Non-Professional Use

製品を使ってみた感想： I wouldn't use DesignSpark as a main CAD software in industry as it is missing some features and to be honest I don't think that was ever it's intention. It is great for school kids and older students who want to submit a drawing for manufacture or just want to get the hang of using CAD software.

良いポイント:

It has many of the important / necessary features required to create a part or drawing, so somebody with little CAD experience can quickly produce something that can be submitted to a workshop. It also runs well as it isn't a cloud based solution.

改善してほしい点:

Whilst being off the cloud makes it run well, it also means it can't be used without administrator rights to install, which can make it prohibitive for use on a large organisations network. But for less formal use on personal computers, it's great!